Get a demo Do I subscribe? News sign-up
Download PDF

Andrex Flushed With Triumph At Court Verdict

News, 01 June 1997

KIMBERLY CLARK won the day in its legal spat with fellow lavatory paper purveyor Fort Sterling. The latter launched a new loo-roll product Nouvelle in 1996, majoring on softness as its prime selling proposition. This theme was developed in an on-pack promotion which stated: 'Softness guaranteed - or we’ll exchange it for Andrex'. The promo’s small print clearly stated that Andrex was a competitive brand unconnected with Fort Sterling. This, however, cut no ice with the mighty KC which promptly sought a High Court injunction on the grounds of passing-off. Mr Justice Laddie found in favour of KC in as much as Fort Sterling’s disclaimer 'was insufficiently prominent to avoid an implication, certainly on first sight, that Andrex must be a related product to Nouvelle'. However, the view of ISP legal advisor Philip Circus is that the ruling does not imply that the basic concept of exchanging a product with a competitor’s brand is wrong or unsound. It is not the technique itself that was ruled out of order by the court, but the way it was presented on pack.