Pinpoint the case evidence you need – search by industry, objective, media and more.
Creative TV and video executions from the most innovative and market-leading brands.
Browse campaigns from the world's leading advertising and marketing effectiveness awards.
The latest from our annual case study competitions.
Our ranking of the world's best marketing campaigns and companies.
Browse Warc by subject.
Brands & branding
Consumer research & insight
Media channels & touchpoints
Key Warc papers on marketing best practice.
In-depth analysis of 200 global brand owners.
Develop your skills as a marketing strategist.
Latest reports from Warc and trusted partners offering unique insights into current trends.
The driving forces behind consumer behaviour.
New developments for industries and sectors.
Strategic insight for the marketing of brands.
Media & Tech
Latest innovations in media and technology.
Insight and intelligence for countries and regions.
Daily coverage of key developments for marketers worldwide.
The Warc Blog
Insights, opinions and fresh new thinking from our team of bloggers around the world.
Forecasts and Data Homepage
Overview of databases, forecasts and reports.
Annual ad expenditure data for 90 markets.
International Ad Forecast
Warc's forecasts for adspend in 12 key markets.
Consensus Ad Forecast
Adspend forecast aggregating several sources.
Media Costs Database
Compare costs across media and markets.
Global Marketing Index
A monthly indicator of the state of the industry.
Key briefings from major conferences and events in the US, Europe and Asia Pacific.
Plan your schedule of must-attend events with our global calendar of conferences.
Learn how to tackle key marketing challenges from leading experts in our series of in-depth webinars.
Content & Partners
What Our Clients Say
Request a Trial
For our market-leading publications and events
Contact us on +1 202 778 0680
Do I Subscribe?
The Warc Blog
The Warc Blog
Feedback / Complaints
Other Blogs We Like
Account Planning Group UK
Account Planning Methods
ANA: Marketing Musings
Brand Keys: The Keyhole
Garfield at Large
Harvard Business Review
Joe la pompe
Market Research Society
One Size Fits One
Straight Talk with Nigel Hollis
The Warc Blog
The danger of creative award targets
As I whiled away the hours at Brussels Midi station waiting in hope and in confusion for a Eurostar train to get me back to London, it became clear that the law of unintended consequences was at work.
It has, of course, derailed many a well-intentioned policy.
In the UK, for example, NHS targets have resulted in distortions to patient care; educational targets have led to the abandonment of non-core subjects and so on. Back in Brussels unbeknownst to all, the train I was booked on had been cancelled and all passengers transferred to the next train, thereby displacing all its passengers onto the subsequent train.
No one had any idea which train they were entitled to board: the resulting entirely unnecessary confusion and angst amongst passengers was pitiful to see. Why would any business risk such alienation of its customers if it were not for the fact that by cancelling a train rather than allowing it to leave 3 hours late, the company’s targets and penalties would be less jeopardised?
Charles Goodhart identified the dangers of using performance metrics as targets in his eponymous law. An advisor to the Bank of England, Goodhart noticed that as soon as a metric was turned into a target, it lost its value as a measure of success.
The most obvious reason for this is that other facets of performance that had once correlated with the chosen metric, cease to do so because they are deliberately de-prioritised in order to pursue the target: the metric no longer remains a useful broader indicator of success and often becomes counterproductive.
An elegant example of this is the apparent contradiction between the robust PIMS finding that profitability correlates closely with market share and the similarly robust finding of Wharton and Monash professors Armstrong and Green, that companies that pursue market share as a primary target actually lose profitability.
The unintended consequence here is the buying of market share through non-profitable means such as discounting and price-promotion: target achieved, but at a cost.
Why my sudden interest in Goodhart’s law? Ever since I wrote a report for the UK-based Institute of Practitioners in Advertising (IPA) entitled ‘The link between creativity and effectiveness’, I have become increasingly uncomfortable about the level and nature of interest shown in the study by creative agencies.
Naturally it is nice to have interest shown in one’s work, but just in case the report is used to suggest that creativity should become a target for agencies or their management teams, let me explain why Goodhart’s law is especially relevant here.
The analysis I conducted showed that campaigns in the IPA databank that had won at least one major creative award (as measured by the Gunn Report) were on average 11 times more efficient than those that had not.
Whilst this suggests that creatively awarded campaigns are more likely to be commercially successful, it does not mean that they all are – indeed in Donald Gunn’s landmark 1996 study, he found that around 14% of creatively awarded campaigns failed to show any commercial success: usually because the strategy was wrong.
What the IPA analysis actually demonstrates is that creatively awarded strategically sound campaigns are 11 times more efficient than non-creative but strategically sound campaigns. No amount of pure creative genius will turn a misguided strategy into a commercial success.
The IPA analysis demonstrates that you need to focus on both effectiveness and creativity to hit the sweet spot. So an agency that targets creative awards alone as its key output success metric runs a very great risk of undermining the value of that creativity as a result of Goodhart’s law: because the drive for creative awards will mean deprioritising effectiveness.
Perhaps this already happens - there are many very conspicuously creatively awarded campaigns that never seem to submit effectiveness case studies. If I were a client of one of these campaigns I would want to know why.
So the warning to clients and other creative agency stakeholders is this: if your agency pursues creative award targets, ensure that it also has effectiveness award targets. If not, Goodhart’s law may see your growth plans derailed.
17 December 2010 17:27
comments on this blog
Add your comment here:
Posting your comment.... please wait
Saturation point: Desktop internet adspend to decline this year
Point of view: Trust and social media
When purpose becomes a problem
Mythbuster: Attribution fraud
Should advertisers invest in ‘moment marketing’?
Point of view: The social media detox
Time to synchronise
Beats by Dre: R/GA - Old school marketing to a new generation
Limber Up: Strategy & Planning – The Agile Way
Hover cars, branded content and guanxi at Cannes' China Day